User talk:Xeeron/Policy

two things. Discretion: "Discretion can also be seen as equal to the amount of "fuzzyness" in policy wording". It is not only the interpretation of a policy, it can be also any action which do not have a policy or do not fall into consideration of any policy. For example right now on gw2w there is no policies all the admins have is discretion and so there is no "interpretation of policies". It can be discussed also about how many policies are needed or if some can be left to the admins discretion. Recalls and elections: The time they are applied is independent from what they are, for example there could be elections only when there is a complain on an admin but not on a period base, also there could be a period based recalls on sysops, for example: "sysops are subject to a reconfirmation every year" and it would still be a recall and not an election. Coran Ironclaw 17:52, 5 January 2008 (UTC)

"Admins are detached from the community. In the end, they form the wiki how they want it to be instead of forming the wiki like the community wants it to be. The community does not have any tool to enforce its view." I believe that anyone who has ever been a part of the GWiki community would disagree with you. The community only selects the admins who are a part of the community, and most if not all of them are very open to suggestions a comments on their talk pages. Lord Belar 18:12, 5 January 2008 (UTC)

For your info, I was a very active part of that community for a long time. --Xeeron 19:28, 5 January 2008 (UTC)

I think he's right Lord.reanor 16:30, 6 January 2008 (UTC)