File talk:Gunk.jpg

New version

I think wielded is better. When it's on the ground, you can't tell what it's supposed to be at all. I should say in the ground with the way it clips through it. Wielded, it still looks like a mess but it looks like a basket of... something. Plus it has that smoke effect which is part of its appearance you can't see when it's on the ground and just has the generic item sparkles instead. If somebody could take a shot of it wielded by a Norn (to try and make it as big as possible), when the snowstorm isn't there (for the brightness) I think that would be as good as we could get. My only Norn is an ele so she ruins it with her unremovable elemental bracelet. -Azurem (talk) 13:49, 6 December 2016 (UTC)

It's a pretty small object, and it's easier for players to identify it in game if the picture we have here is of it not being held, just it by itself. The smoke part could be notated on the page, or a separate picture could be taken, and to be honest, I thought the previous picture had grass in the way, if that was it being held, I had no idea. - Do_odleplex 18:14, 6 December 2016 (UTC)

No idea what you're talking about with grass in the way, there's nothing in front of it. The sylvari arm definitely blends in too much, but a human/norn arm would be pretty identifiable I think. Players are not going to use the image to identify it because it's so small they're mostly just going to see the big sparkle trail and the words "Mushroom Fertilizer". I think the image should show what the object actually looks like which your image... doesn't. It makes it look like a potato with wings. -Azurem (talk) 19:46, 6 December 2016 (UTC)

I always preferred wielded images for bundles. Some are way too small to have a 'on-the-floor' image. If we could get a larger, brighter shot of the wielded bundle, that'd be great. —Ventriloquist 20:28, 6 December 2016 (UTC)

In the case, I think the bundle is too small to be shown in the hand, as that would mostly show the hand holding it and not the actual object, which I just realized is a small ball of poo. Ew. >_< - Do_odleplex 20:38, 6 December 2016 (UTC)

There's no hand holding it, your hand just kind of goes inside it. It replaces your hand. Do walking mushrooms poo? Do they poo in carved wooden potties which they carry around with them for quaggans to collect and use as gloves? :S -Azurem (talk) 21:01, 6 December 2016 (UTC)